Garrett Moon

Why Emotional Headlines are Good for Your Content Marketing

By: Garrett Moon | December 3, 2014 | 
34

Why Emotional Headlines Are Actually Good For Your Content MarketingBy Garrett Moon

When I say emotional headlines you say… bleh.

But, maybe you shouldn’t write them off so quickly.

One look at your Facebook news feed reveals that emotional headlines influence what visitors are seeing online.

Sites such as Buzzfeed and Upworthy are filling our news feed with emotional headlines, and we’re clicking on them–a lot.

OK, maybe not you (yeah, right), but someone is clicking on them and that matters.

Whether you love them or hate them, you should be talking notice and learning what you can from their success. And, you CAN learn something.

Not long ago at CoSchedule (a social editorial calendar for WordPress) we reached a milestone of one million headlines in our database.

We decided to take the opportunity to learn what exactly made one headline better than the other. The data was interesting, but you’ll never guess what stood out.

Yes, emotional headlines.

Emotional Headlines Work

We compiled a list of headlines in our system and the total number of shares that each post received online.

Assuming that posts with more shares were more popular, we then took a subset of those headlines and tried to figure out what made them so good.

Common words in highly shared headlines included things such as you/your, free/giveaway, how to, and many of the typical phrases that we’ve seen before.

It wasn’t until we starting looking at the emotional side of words that things really got interesting.

We started testing the most (and least) shared headlines using the Emotional Marketing Value (EMV) Headline Analyzer as made available by the Advanced Marketing Institute.

This handy little tool uses its custom algorithm to rank the emotional value of a headline.

According to the Advanced Marketing Institute:

Most professional copywriters’ headlines will have 30-40 percent EMV Words in their headlines, while the most gifted copywriters will have 50-75 percent EMV words in headlines.

The interesting thing is that we were able to verify that there was a direct correlation to the number of shares and the emotional value of a headline.

The Data to Prove it

To test, we took an average sampling of headlines in three different sharing groups.

  • Posts with greater than 1,000 shares.
  • Posts with 500 shares.
  • Posts with 100 shares.

Here are the results:

Screen Shot 2014-11-22 at 9.57.46 PM

The results showed there was a direct (and significant) correlation between “viral” content and the overall emotional value of the headline.

We compared the data to a few popular blogs that are already using this tactic to their advantage and found similar results.

Screen Shot 2014-11-22 at 9.59.47 PM

Here’s the deal: Emotional words make for emotional headlines and those kind of headlines get shared. They always have.

We’ve all read The National Enquirer while waiting in line at the grocery store, even if we’re pretending not to.

Emotions work, but that doesn’t make them bad. You should think twice if you tend to shrug them off.

Will emotional headlines get you more shares and more traffic?

Probably.

Does it mean that you are the next Buzzfeed?

Probably not.

Incorporating Emotion into Your Content

Too much of a good thing can be wrong (ahem… Buzzfeed), but my point is we need to stop being mad at the method, and start embracing the reality of our audience.

We need to better understand why people actually share content in the first place.

According to a study conducted by The New York Times Customer Insight Group, there are six reasons that people share things online.

  1. To bring valuable and entertaining content to others. Nearly half (49%) say sharing allows them to inform others of products they care about and potentially change opinions or encourage action.
  2. To define ourselves to others. Almost three-quarters (68%) share to give people a better sense of who they are and what they care about.
  3. To grow and nourish our relationships. More than three-quarters (78%) share information online because it lets them stay connected to people they may not otherwise stay in touch with.
  4. Self-fulfillment. Nearly three-quarters (69%) share information because it allows them to feel more involved in the world.
  5. To get the word out about causes or brands. Close to all (84%) share because it is a way to support causes or issues they care about.

All-in-all, these are highly emotional reasons that go deep into our own personal fulfillment and value.

This means sharing the content you create is not a mechanical process carefully weighed by the over quality of your post. Rather, it is an emotional response to a rather emotional process.

Perhaps these emotional headlines aren’t so bad, after all. Perhaps they could be an asset to your content marketing after-all.

What do you think? Can headlines be emotional without being Buzzfeed?

Note from Gini: If you want to try this on some of your own headlines, Garrett and his team just launched a headline analyzer. Check it out!

About Garrett Moon


Garrett Moon is a co-founder at CoSchedule, a social media editorial calendar for WordPress that allows users to schedule blogs posts and social media on an easy drag-and-drop calendar. He blogs about social media and content marketing every week on the CoSchedule Content Marketing blog.

  • I just had my first Coschedule experience (when I did a guest post for Fitfluential) so “hi”! I hope it’s possible for headlines to be emotionally gripping w/o being BuzzFeed.  It does fascinate me when formulas work. I downloaded a “best headlines” thing from Pinterest or something once and decided (lacking anything else creative” to go with one of them. My “Top Ten Tips for New Bloggers” was one of my most commented on posts … and I figure that’s at least partially due to the formula “top ten tips” but hopefully a tiny bit to the content! Ultimately there still has to be something interesting to read no matter how much the headline gets you to click …. ideally.

  • biggreenpen Paula’s right (and first!). You have to have something to back up your headline. 
    That said, what an interesting idea, and an interesting tool! I’m curious how they compute that figure. I mean, I didn’t think your headline was super emotional (I suppose the word “good” has some emotional connotation) but it got a 44%. Now I just want to play with this more …

  • ginidietrich

    garrett_moon That’s you!

  • garrett_moon

    ginidietrich Ha! Noticed that after it was too late. oh well!

  • ginidietrich

    garrett_moon I love it!

  • garrett_moon

    ginidietrich Multi-tasking while tweeting is a bad combo. Lesson learned

  • ginidietrich

    garrett_moon I once tweeted my bank account PW so I understand!

  • Eleanor Pierce biggreenpen Yeah, I was interested in the same thing. How is a emotional value really analyzed?

  • This quote makes you think- we need to stop being mad at the method, and start embracing the reality of our audience.

    No doubt there are numerous similar methods like that out there, how can we learn from them and use them in a effective and worthwhile (i.e. non-spinny or spammy) way. There is a reason why some of these tactics work. Smart marketers won’t just dismiss them, but use what we can learn from them in a better way.

  • You know what this makes me want to do? An analysis of our headlines. It’s going to be a holiday vacation project!

  • BCMparacafres

    JeffSheehan SpinSucks , emotional sells, what a discovery!

  • garrett_moon

    JonMikelBailey Thanks for sharing! We actually just launched a headline analyzer tool (http://coschedule.com/headline-analyzer) Would love your feedback!

  • garrett_moon

    lizabutcher Thanks for sharing! We actually just launched a headline analyzer tool (http://coschedule.com/headline-analyzer) Would love your feedback!

  • garrett_moon

    neicolec Thanks 4 the share! We actually just launched a headline analyzer tool (http://coschedule.com/headline-analyzer) Would love your feedback 🙂

  • garrett_moon

    ROWebTalk Thanks for sharing! We actually just launched a headline analyzer tool (http://coschedule.com/headline-analyzer) Would love your feedback!

  • garrett_moon

    ginidietrich Cool thing, and unplanned, but we just launched a headline analyzer tool today! http://coschedule.com/headline-analyzer

  • kateeidam

    garrett_moon Will definitely check it out. Thanks!

  • garrett_moon

    LauraPetrolino Well said!

  • garrett_moon

    ginidietrich Ha – good call! We actually just launched an analyzer that combines this emotional stuff with SEO and other best practices: http://coschedule.com/headline-analyzer

  • lkpetrolino

    garrett_moon Awesome Garrett! I’ll definitely check it out!

  • Pingback: Public Relations- Final Post | kathrynamann()

  • JamboTw

    garrett_moon My pleasure! As for the headline analyzer: “Huge gift, instructive and practical challenge, excellent reward” – score 85 🙂

  • garrett_moon

    JamboTw Hmm, we may not give you the Headline Analyzer Guarantee on that one 😉

  • ginidietrich

    garrett_moon Nice! I’ll check it out! Do you want me to add that to your blog post?

  • garrett_moon

    ginidietrich Oh, I’d love that! Want me to write something up?

  • ginidietrich

    garrett_moon If it’s cool with you, I’ll just link it to the emotional headlines post.

  • garrett_moon

    ginidietrich Yep, that’s cool with me. Thanks!

  • ginidietrich

    garrett_moon Done!

  • ginidietrich

    garrett_moon OK – it’s at the bottom of the post now.

  • Pingback: Weekly Rewind: Dec. 1 - 7 | Cooper Smith Agency Public Relations()

  • TwumblrGram

    markwschaefer just shared your tweet on my site: http://rbl.ms/1vxlH74

  • Pingback: Twelve Digital Tools You'll Be Using More of in 2015 by @jessostroff Spin Sucks()

  • Pingback: A Content Strategy Fit for an Oscar by @kerrygorgone Spin Sucks()

  • Millabrain

    Howdy! Quick
    question that’s entirely off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile
    friendly? My blog looks weird when browsing from my iphone. I’m trying to
    find a theme or plugin that might be able to resolve this issue. If you have
    any recommendations, please share. Cheers!
    http://www.finanauto.com

470 Shares
Buffer29
Tweet312
Share40
Share76
+113