If you’re a regular reader of Spin Sucks, you know I’m an advocate of attacking an idea, but not a person. There is way too much agreement in the social media chamber. Unfortunately, if someone disagrees with you, they typically won’t comment or say anything. They just stop reading.
And that’s a shame. The only way we learn is to debate with an open mind. If we surround ourselves with people who agree with us all the time, we’ll stall.
Over here, when we see something that seems crazy to us, we blog about it. After all, the name of the blog is Spin Sucks.
But Arik made me stop and think about whether or not we’re doing our clients, prospective clients, and the industry a service by talking about the things everyone can learn from flameouts.
There are some really good comments on the blog post, but I especially like what Scott Hepburn said.
While I agree with Scott, this also gave me reason to stop and think. Do we subconsciously do those things when we blog about mishaps? When I jokingly said we should have a weekly Moron Award, was I sending a message that Arment Dietrich is the only integrated marketing and communication firm that knows what it’s doing?
But the conclusion I came to is that, while I think both Arik and Scott are right and there likely are bloggers and “experts” who put people down in order to pump themselves up, our goal here is to provide professional development for PR and marketing pros. And sometimes that includes showing examples of how not to do things in order to avoid the same mistakes in the future.
When it comes down to it, there is a big difference between laughing at failures of others and learning from their mistakes. After all, if we had to learn everything all by ourselves, the world wouldn’t move as quickly as it does.