Gini Dietrich

Walmart Fighting Hunger Campaign Is A PR Mess

By: Gini Dietrich | January 11, 2011 | 
73

No matter how you feel about the way Walmart does business, you have to admire the fact that they always try new PR strategies before any0ne else does. Granted, they also tend to fall all over themselves in the process. But they are always one of the first major corporations to try new technologies.

Remember the “Walmarting Across America” blog in 2006? It featured the journey of a couple traveling from Las Vegas to Georgia in an RV, who captured lives and stories along the way, and parked for free in Walmart parking lots. They interviewed store clerks and executives, all who seemingly loved their jobs.

And then BusinessWeek discovered that, in fact, the couple had been hired to blog as a publicity stunt.

Cue a bunch of people being fired, including their PR firm. It was a disaster, but they’re lucky it didn’t happen into today’s blogosphere. It was too early … blogging was still really new back then and not many blogs existed. They were confined to the wrath solely of mass media (which is bad enough as it is).

Enter the 2010 holiday season”Fighting Hunger” campaign, which used Facebook and its own website to communicate the contest, but also to rally communities together to, well, fight hunger.

Again, a seemingly great idea.

Walmart hosted its first nationwide food drive at all of their stores. They called on their Facebook fans to select communities to receive $1.5 million in grants. They donated 65 refrigerator food trucks to Feeding America network food banks. And they helped The Salvation Army provide meals with a $1 million donation.

I can’t find how many families they helped with their nationwide food drive, but a donation of $2.5 million and 65 food trucks isn’t a small feat.

So how did it go so wrong?

Well, according to the Fresno Bee (the city that came in second; my hometown of Salt Lake City won the $1 million grant), it was a PR disaster.

From the story:

“So if good PR was the goal, Walmart stumbled and bumbled its way through this campaign. It started with the “FAQ” section of the contest site, which read like it was starving for a good copywriter.

Because the rules weren’t clear, all hell broke loose on Facebook during the last week of the contest. What exactly were you supposed to “like?” Links? Comments? Could people vote multiple times? Could people create new Facebook pages just to have a like-and-comment bonanza? Could people use technology tricks such as the “macro-like”? And, really, how many times did you refresh the Fighting Hunger site and ALL the votes were gone?”

It turns out that what they were communicating through their website and to the media and what they were putting on Facebook were two different things. And, one day they were saying people could vote more than once and the next they were going to remove the people who voted more than once or who used autobots to vote.

Their own FAQ, still on the Fighting Hunger website, contradicts what they have on Facebook and the criteria they used to determine the final winner.

Here is what I don’t get: How can Walmart not have marketing and PR professionals who are savvy enough to think through all of these things? They work with the best and the brightest in our field, yet no one seems to be minding the store.

We are but a speck on the radar of a gigantic corporation like Walmart, but they should have read our “Facebook Contests: Seven Tips for Flawless Execution.”

I think this is the pretty, shiny new penny syndrome.  Hey! Let’s give away $1 million on Facebook and see how it works.

Hello? Strategy? A full understanding of what works and what doesn’t work?

What do you think?

About Gini Dietrich


Gini Dietrich is the founder and CEO of Arment Dietrich, an integrated marketing communications firm. She is the author of Spin Sucks, co-author of Marketing in the Round, and co-host of Inside PR. She also is the lead blogger at Spin Sucks and is the founder of Spin Sucks Pro.

Spin Sucks in Your Inbox

Leave a Reply

73 Comments on "Walmart Fighting Hunger Campaign Is A PR Mess"

avatar

Sort by:   newest | oldest
TravisMClemens
TravisMClemens
5 years 4 months ago

I’m not sure I agree with you. Yeah, there were some details that didn’t come off perfectly, but as far as PR goes, I think they showed exactly the kind of competition that garners good publicity. I had a lot of people who I know HATE Wal-mart who were not only “liking” it, but also encouraging (sometimes begging) their entire network of friends to do the same. Skeptics became advocates.

So I would say the goodwill they built up with people more than overshadowed the difficulties they faced throughout the competition.

TravisMClemens
TravisMClemens
5 years 4 months ago

I’m not sure I agree with you. Yeah, there were some details that didn’t come off perfectly, but as far as PR goes, I think they showed exactly the kind of competition that garners good publicity. I had a lot of people who I know HATE Wal-mart who were not only “liking” it, but also encouraging (sometimes begging) their entire network of friends to do the same. Skeptics became advocates.

So I would say the goodwill they built up with people more than overshadowed the difficulties they faced throughout the competition.

wabbitoid
5 years 4 months ago
That was strangely heartening. First there’s the schadenfreude of watching a big chain screw up, which I always like. But it makes me feel a lot better about this nagging feeling I have that I’m constantly repeating m’self as I try to refine how I communicate the need for strategy to my very small biz clients. If Wal*Mart can screw up big, there’s a good reason they are confoozed. We are all practitioners in a new field – one where the instant-cool factor tends towards sloppiness and impulse. I’m going to dig into this story a little more to see… Read more »
wabbitoid
5 years 4 months ago
That was strangely heartening. First there’s the schadenfreude of watching a big chain screw up, which I always like. But it makes me feel a lot better about this nagging feeling I have that I’m constantly repeating m’self as I try to refine how I communicate the need for strategy to my very small biz clients. If Wal*Mart can screw up big, there’s a good reason they are confoozed. We are all practitioners in a new field – one where the instant-cool factor tends towards sloppiness and impulse. I’m going to dig into this story a little more to see… Read more »
FocusedWords
FocusedWords
5 years 4 months ago

Good Morning Gini,

I suspect that Walmart has fallen into the age old problem of the right hand doesn’t know what the left hand is doing. For some unfathomable reason, companies do not have any respect for SM. They don’t seem to realize that SM is not one thing and therefore they don’t worry about coordinating any efforts. But then this is from my personal experience with my current client.

FocusedWords
FocusedWords
5 years 4 months ago

Good Morning Gini,

I suspect that Walmart has fallen into the age old problem of the right hand doesn’t know what the left hand is doing. For some unfathomable reason, companies do not have any respect for SM. They don’t seem to realize that SM is not one thing and therefore they don’t worry about coordinating any efforts. But then this is from my personal experience with my current client.

wabbitoid
5 years 4 months ago

@FocusedWords That’s sort of what I was thinking when I read this. Most of my clients are single prop / manager operations – and even when it’s one person running the whole show SM is often seen as “different”. Making it all work together seems to be the hard part, from the sign out on the sidewalk to the blog to the media buys and back to what is said when a customer comes in the door.

wabbitoid
5 years 4 months ago

@FocusedWords That’s sort of what I was thinking when I read this. Most of my clients are single prop / manager operations – and even when it’s one person running the whole show SM is often seen as “different”. Making it all work together seems to be the hard part, from the sign out on the sidewalk to the blog to the media buys and back to what is said when a customer comes in the door.

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago
@TravisMClemens I think may have to agree to disagree. I’m not a believer in all PR is good PR. Sure, there were TONS of likes for this program, but it wasn’t for Walmart, it was for the individual cities (according to the Fighting Hunger website). I’m not a Walmart fan, but I would certainly have liked one of the community pages to help them win the grant. Or I would have liked the Walmar page through the contest and then deleted them. They do have three million “fans” on their corporate site, but I’d love to know what the numbers… Read more »
ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago
@TravisMClemens I think may have to agree to disagree. I’m not a believer in all PR is good PR. Sure, there were TONS of likes for this program, but it wasn’t for Walmart, it was for the individual cities (according to the Fighting Hunger website). I’m not a Walmart fan, but I would certainly have liked one of the community pages to help them win the grant. Or I would have liked the Walmar page through the contest and then deleted them. They do have three million “fans” on their corporate site, but I’d love to know what the numbers… Read more »
TravisMClemens
TravisMClemens
5 years 4 months ago

@ginidietrich
Yeah, I wasn’t trying to change your opinion, and I agree, not all PR is good PR. But in this case with the amount of people who got actively involved and advocated for it and talked about it with their colleagues and friends, I would say the overall takeaway for the average person was, “Wow, Wal-Mart donated a lot of money to my community.”

As PR professionals, we can learn from their shortcomings, but I think this accomplished their ultimate goal.

So let’s agree, that we disagree. 🙂

TravisMClemens
TravisMClemens
5 years 4 months ago

@ginidietrich
Yeah, I wasn’t trying to change your opinion, and I agree, not all PR is good PR. But in this case with the amount of people who got actively involved and advocated for it and talked about it with their colleagues and friends, I would say the overall takeaway for the average person was, “Wow, Wal-Mart donated a lot of money to my community.”

As PR professionals, we can learn from their shortcomings, but I think this accomplished their ultimate goal.

So let’s agree, that we disagree. 🙂

nateriggs
nateriggs
5 years 4 months ago

Haha. Good post and good points. Keep in mind to that the wonderful Wal-Mart folks were responsible for the whole RV Wal-Mart paid bloggers debacle a few years back. I think that was probably agency driven, but it seems like whoever is advising them on strategy and execution still mastered how to make the social web work in their favor. With as much inconsistency of information as there was, seems like basic project management is illusive as well. If I were at in charge at Wal-Mart, I’d hire you guys today… 🙂

nateriggs
nateriggs
5 years 4 months ago

Haha. Good post and good points. Keep in mind to that the wonderful Wal-Mart folks were responsible for the whole RV Wal-Mart paid bloggers debacle a few years back. I think that was probably agency driven, but it seems like whoever is advising them on strategy and execution still mastered how to make the social web work in their favor. With as much inconsistency of information as there was, seems like basic project management is illusive as well. If I were at in charge at Wal-Mart, I’d hire you guys today… 🙂

trackback

[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Nancy Byron. Nancy Byron said: RT @Steveology: Walmart Fighting Hunger Campaign Is A PR Mess | Spin Sucks http://ow.ly/3BVGQ […]

HowieSPM
HowieSPM
5 years 4 months ago
This is no different from what Facebook goes through. They have select facts on a fact page that contradicts all their press releases. Obviously high schoolers help Zuckerberg when it comes to prep before being interviewed about privacy and all the rest of the BS. Walmart isn’t moving any sales needles via Social. They never will. Maybe it was the Agency of Record who decided to help with positive PR no matter how small they should do a Pepsi Refresh type project in hopes of free Impressions and PR? So many things are not repeatable. And so many companies bungle… Read more »
HowieSPM
HowieSPM
5 years 4 months ago
This is no different from what Facebook goes through. They have select facts on a fact page that contradicts all their press releases. Obviously high schoolers help Zuckerberg when it comes to prep before being interviewed about privacy and all the rest of the BS. Walmart isn’t moving any sales needles via Social. They never will. Maybe it was the Agency of Record who decided to help with positive PR no matter how small they should do a Pepsi Refresh type project in hopes of free Impressions and PR? So many things are not repeatable. And so many companies bungle… Read more »
Steveology
Steveology
5 years 4 months ago

Strategy Smatergy 😉

Steveology
Steveology
5 years 4 months ago

Strategy Smatergy 😉

GordonMarcy
GordonMarcy
5 years 4 months ago

“Making it all work together.” Synergy. What in the world is so hard to understand about that. Marketing 101. Maybe it’s on purpose, to see what would happen. Nah! I wouldn’t go so far as to say that WM will never get it. When you’re one of the world’s biggest corporations you can afford a few false starts. Hopefully, content about them is being monitored and someone of importance is reading it.

GordonMarcy
GordonMarcy
5 years 4 months ago

“Making it all work together.” Synergy. What in the world is so hard to understand about that. Marketing 101. Maybe it’s on purpose, to see what would happen. Nah! I wouldn’t go so far as to say that WM will never get it. When you’re one of the world’s biggest corporations you can afford a few false starts. Hopefully, content about them is being monitored and someone of importance is reading it.

NowShareThis
NowShareThis
5 years 4 months ago
Great post. Shocks me that “big” company like WalMart can get such terrible PR advice/service. Just reaffirms what I learned transitioning from Journalism career into PR a few years back: There are PR people out there who don’t know what the heck they are doing, but they talk a good enough game and the customer/client doesn’t know enough to contradict them or call them out on their BS, so the client/customer forks over the money to the PR person/firm and chaos ensues. Then like any good PR person the PR firm can blame someone else or “spin” the outcome. Not… Read more »
NowShareThis
NowShareThis
5 years 4 months ago
Great post. Shocks me that “big” company like WalMart can get such terrible PR advice/service. Just reaffirms what I learned transitioning from Journalism career into PR a few years back: There are PR people out there who don’t know what the heck they are doing, but they talk a good enough game and the customer/client doesn’t know enough to contradict them or call them out on their BS, so the client/customer forks over the money to the PR person/firm and chaos ensues. Then like any good PR person the PR firm can blame someone else or “spin” the outcome. Not… Read more »
Sushi
5 years 4 months ago

@FocusedWords I was also thinking this. Walmart is such a huge company that in order to get anything done, one has to jump through about ten different hoops, and hoop three could contradict hoop seven, which could contradict hoop five, and next thing you know, you get a mess like this campaign.

Sushi
5 years 4 months ago

@FocusedWords I was also thinking this. Walmart is such a huge company that in order to get anything done, one has to jump through about ten different hoops, and hoop three could contradict hoop seven, which could contradict hoop five, and next thing you know, you get a mess like this campaign.

FollowtheLawyer
FollowtheLawyer
5 years 4 months ago

My experience with cases like these — direct and indirect — is not that there are too few smart, capable and experienced people involved, but too many, with varying levels of influence/control and different objectives.

FollowtheLawyer
FollowtheLawyer
5 years 4 months ago

My experience with cases like these — direct and indirect — is not that there are too few smart, capable and experienced people involved, but too many, with varying levels of influence/control and different objectives.

EricaAllison
5 years 4 months ago
While I love to hear how Walmart goofed, it appears as if it was their crack team of PR and Marketing pros who missed a step or two. What I found most useful about this post however was your link to your earlier post on making Facebook Contests work. Having tried a few for my clients, I can tell you they are a pain in the tush and most of mine were misses, rather than hits – esp when measured by how much people participated via FB. Offline, the contests generated buzz and brought people to the door, so in… Read more »
EricaAllison
5 years 4 months ago
While I love to hear how Walmart goofed, it appears as if it was their crack team of PR and Marketing pros who missed a step or two. What I found most useful about this post however was your link to your earlier post on making Facebook Contests work. Having tried a few for my clients, I can tell you they are a pain in the tush and most of mine were misses, rather than hits – esp when measured by how much people participated via FB. Offline, the contests generated buzz and brought people to the door, so in… Read more »
JamesDBurrell2
5 years 4 months ago
Gasp. I am a huge walmart shopper. But echoing what @FocusedWords @wabbitoid @Sushi said earlier, this does seem like a situation where there were a lot of Chiefs and too few Indians (the left not knowing what the right was doing euphemism had already been used). As far as its ability to gander good will for Wal-Mart corporate, I’m not sure this contest was a success — at least not in my estimation. I was well aware of the contest but completely clueless as how to ‘rightfully’ help out my town, and like I said, I’m a regular shopper. Seems… Read more »
JamesDBurrell2
5 years 4 months ago
Gasp. I am a huge walmart shopper. But echoing what @FocusedWords @wabbitoid @Sushi said earlier, this does seem like a situation where there were a lot of Chiefs and too few Indians (the left not knowing what the right was doing euphemism had already been used). As far as its ability to gander good will for Wal-Mart corporate, I’m not sure this contest was a success — at least not in my estimation. I was well aware of the contest but completely clueless as how to ‘rightfully’ help out my town, and like I said, I’m a regular shopper. Seems… Read more »
Calistyle
Calistyle
5 years 4 months ago

Great post Gini and a good reminder for all of us working with brands to remember K.I.S.S. when it comes to promotions. Oh, and a solid strategy is a good idea too. 🙂

Calistyle
Calistyle
5 years 4 months ago

Great post Gini and a good reminder for all of us working with brands to remember K.I.S.S. when it comes to promotions. Oh, and a solid strategy is a good idea too. 🙂

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@EricaAllison I don’t think. though, it was external influences, do you? I think this is Walmart corporate, based on what I read. And…glad you found our mistakes helpful! 🙂

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@EricaAllison I don’t think. though, it was external influences, do you? I think this is Walmart corporate, based on what I read. And…glad you found our mistakes helpful! 🙂

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@Calistyle GREAT point about KISS! Really, really good advice.

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@Calistyle GREAT point about KISS! Really, really good advice.

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@JamesDBurrell2 We’ve already had the Walmart vs. Target discussion and I know you make $7 sweat pants look like a million bucks (sigh). But I do agree with you that there were too many cooks in the kitchen.

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@JamesDBurrell2 We’ve already had the Walmart vs. Target discussion and I know you make $7 sweat pants look like a million bucks (sigh). But I do agree with you that there were too many cooks in the kitchen.

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@FollowtheLawyer Yeah…I think you’re right. How do businesses grow without these kinds of issues? Is it just inevitable?

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@FollowtheLawyer Yeah…I think you’re right. How do businesses grow without these kinds of issues? Is it just inevitable?

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@NowShareThis I agree that some PR firms don’t what the heck they’re doing and sell a potential client a bill of goods. But there are also plenty of clients who expect they’re going to hire a PR firm and then achieve status and huge awareness in a month. And, when they don’t, they fire the PR firm. We spend A LOT of time setting expectations with our clients. They look at some of the things we’ve done for other clients and say, “I want that” without fully realizing it’s taken three years to get “that.”

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@NowShareThis I agree that some PR firms don’t what the heck they’re doing and sell a potential client a bill of goods. But there are also plenty of clients who expect they’re going to hire a PR firm and then achieve status and huge awareness in a month. And, when they don’t, they fire the PR firm. We spend A LOT of time setting expectations with our clients. They look at some of the things we’ve done for other clients and say, “I want that” without fully realizing it’s taken three years to get “that.”

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@GordonMarcy Marketing 101. Seems too hard, I think. 🙂

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@GordonMarcy Marketing 101. Seems too hard, I think. 🙂

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@Steveology Oh Steve. Sigh…

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@Steveology Oh Steve. Sigh…

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@HowieSPM I really don’t think it was the agency. I think it was internal.

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@HowieSPM I really don’t think it was the agency. I think it was internal.

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
5 years 4 months ago

@nateriggs Do you really think it was agency driven? Based on what I read, it sounded like an internal PR person was talking to the media and an internal marketing person was updating Facebook. That’s more the departments working in silos instead of the agency not knowing what they’re doing. I hope.

wpDiscuz
[postmatic_subscribe_widget]