TL; DR
Nearly every marketer uses AI to create content now, and it isn’t helping anyone stand out. Orbit Media’s 2026 blogging survey found 92% of content marketers use AI for blogging—and they’re no more likely to report strong results than the people who don’t use it at all.
That’s where E-E-A-T comes in, and no, it isn’t the “25 years of experience” line in your author bio.
Experience is the specific story, the hard-won opinion, and the thing that went sideways. AI can absolutely write the first draft, but it can’t add your people, your process, or your culture—the three things no competitor has and no AI can generate.
Most organizations already have all three. It just never makes it into their content.
Key Insights
- 92% of content marketers use AI for blogging, and AI users are no more likely to report strong results than non-users. AI is table stakes. It isn’t a strategy.
- E-E-A-T isn’t years on the job. Experience is the specific story, the opinion you earned the hard way, and what you learned when something went sideways.
- People: collaborating with experts and influencers is the single best predictor of content success—2.6x the benchmark—yet only 7% of marketers still do it, down from 25% in 2017.
- Process: a formal human editing process beats the benchmark by nearly 2x, while handing the edit to AI performs worst of all. Your method itself, named and documented, is content a competitor can’t copy and AI can cite.
- Culture: what you believe, what you refuse to do, and what you’ve seen that nobody else has. Original research makes strong results 50% more likely, and it’s the content AI cites most consistently.
- In more than 260 PESO Model Diagnostics, nearly half the teams who say they run marketing and communications as a system score low on actual integration. Most teams are coordinated, not integrated.
- Let AI write the first draft. Then add one story, one opinion, and one piece of proof, and ask: could a competitor publish this with their logo on it? If the answer is yes—or even maybe—it’s not finished.
What E-E-A-T Means in the AI Slop Era
I use AI every single day. I loooooove AI. I use it to design my house, give me feedback on my clothes, and help me with my hair and makeup (because I apparently missed the class where they teach you how to do those things). I use it to create weekly meal plans with grocery lists, help me think through thorny situations, learn how to stop avoiding conflict and just be direct, and, of course, I use it at work.
I keep saying I don’t know how I did my job four years ago without AI.
But I don’t let it write for me.
When I recorded the BuzzStream podcast with Vince Nero, he asked how you keep thought leadership from getting lost in the AI slop fest.
I laughed, because this conversation hasn’t changed in 20 years. The tools have changed. The answer hasn’t.
It’s the same one I give my team, our clients, and anyone else who will stand still long enough: You can absolutely, positively let AI write the first draft. But then you, the human, have to add your people, your process, and your culture.
He asked if that was a Gini-ism.
Maybe? I honestly don’t know whether I made it up or borrowed it from someone smarter than me. (If it’s yours, let me know so I can give you credit!) But we say it so often around here that my team could finish the sentence for me.
And it turns out it’s not just a catchphrase. Andy Crestodina and the team at Orbit Media recently released their 2026 blogging survey of 1,042 content marketers, and it backs up the whole thing.
Ninety-two percent of them use AI for blogging. No big surprise there.
But here’s the interesting part: the ones who use AI are no more likely to report strong results than the ones who don’t use it at all.
Both groups sit right around 14%—which, by the way, is the lowest number the survey has ever recorded.
(To be fair, the people not using AI are more likely to report disappointing results. So AI is table stakes. It just isn’t a strategy.)
Think about that for a second. Nearly everyone has the same tool, and the tool isn’t moving the needle.
Which means the tool isn’t your advantage.
What you add to it is.
Experience Isn’t the Line in Your Author Bio
For years now, Google has evaluated your content quality with E-E-A-T—experience, expertise, authority, and trust.
The idea is pretty simple. If you can show you’ve actually done the thing and you know what you’re talking about, authority and trust follow.
Here’s where most people go sideways. When we talked about this on the podcast, Vince floated the response a lot of marketers have: so I just put “25 years of experience” in my author bio, right?
No, no, no, no, no.
(Sorry, Vince.)
Putting years on the job in a bio is not experience. Experience is the specific story. It’s the opinion you earned the hard way. It’s the thing that went sideways in 2019 and what you learned from it. I wrote about this a couple of weeks ago in the thought leadership article—you have to have a thought to be a thought leader.
So the question isn’t “How much experience do we have?” It’s “What makes our experience and expertise different from every other organization in our space?”
There are three answers to that. Your people, your process, and your culture.
Your People
This is where the Orbit data gets kind of nuts.
The single best predictor of content success in the entire survey is collaborating with influencers and experts. The marketers who do it beat the benchmark by 2.6x.
And almost nobody does it anymore! Only 7% of marketers collaborate with experts, down from 25% in 2017.
That’s crazy!
Andy points out that most content programs are just blogs—text-heavy how-to articles that don’t come from any specific person. That’s the slop. It could have been written by anyone. Or anything. (Hello, robots.)
The fix isn’t complicated. Name the expert. Quote them. Tell their stories. Let them disagree with each other.
That works inside and outside your walls. Inside, it’s your own experts, or the people who are the face of the brand. Those who have opinions and aren’t afraid to share them.
(Remember, it doesn’t have to be the CEO. It absolutely can be. It just doesn’t have to be.)
Outside, it’s your customers, your partners, and the people your audience already trusts.
Remember our former client who called my voice-note idea stupid? Well, I showed him. Nobody else on the planet had his opinions. That’s exactly why his content worked—and why he became the name everyone in his industry now knows.
All because he followed through on my stupid voice-note idea.
Your Process
The Orbit team also looked at how marketers edit, and this one made me laugh out loud because it’s so predictable.
Marketers with a formal human editing process are much more likely to report strong results. The human-editor group beats the benchmark by nearly 2x. And the ones who hand the editing over to AI? They perform worse than everyone.
Ann Handley said it best in the report, “AI makes it stupid-easy to remove effort.”
Process is where you put the effort back.
But process isn’t just how you edit. The way you do the work—your framework, your method, your onboarding, your stages—is content, too. It’s something a competitor can’t copy, and it’s something AI can cite. That’s exactly what you’re going for.
I’ll use us as an example.
The PESO Model® is our process. We named it, documented it, and have been talking about it publicly for years (and years and years).
That’s why, when you ask AI how to integrate paid, earned, shared, and owned media, it describes the PESO Model. Not because we gamed anything. Not because we stuffed keywords. Not because we cracked some secret code for how AI works. Because we wrote it down, over and over, in public.
We also have three questions we ask about everything that goes out the door:
- What do you think?
- How will you measure it?
- What is the outcome?
If a draft can’t answer all three, it’s not finished. I don’t care how pretty it is.
Here’s a simple human pass you can add to every AI draft, starting this week: add one story, one opinion, and one piece of proof. Then cut anything that could appear on a competitor’s blog.
And yes, you can use AI to help with that part. Let’s say AI drafted your article (or your video script, or your podcast outline). You’ve added your people, your process, and your culture. Now put it back into AI with this prompt:
You are a tough editor reviewing a blog post before it’s published. Below is the draft. Flag every sentence a competitor in our industry could have written word for word. Flag every claim that has no proof, data, or example behind it. Then identify the three places where a real story, opinion, or result from our team would make the piece stronger, and tell me what kind of story would fit each one. Don’t rewrite anything—just mark it up. Draft: [paste here]
It won’t add the experience for you. But it will show you exactly where it’s missing, which is more than half the battle.
Your Culture (I’ll Show You Ours)
Culture is the hardest of the three to fake, which is exactly why it’s the most valuable. It’s what you believe, what you refuse to do, and what you’ve seen that nobody else has.
I could explain that in the abstract, but it’s way more fun to show you ours.
What We Believe
When I started the blog in 2006 (which was 20 years ago, and I need a moment, because clearly I was only five years old), it wasn’t called Spin Sucks. It was called FADS, or the Fight Against Destructive Spin.
I know. I know! The acronym had zero punch. (Naming things is hard, OK?) So it became Spin Sucks.
The name came from years of introducing myself as a PR pro and watching people’s faces change like I’d just told them I lie for a living. Hollywood and Washington had defined an entire industry of ethical communicators as spin doctors, and I was tired of it.
So the name says it plainly: spin is bad for business, and it’s the opposite of good communications.
Twenty years later, I still believe that with my whole heart.
What We Refuse to Do
Every culture has a stop list, whether it’s written down or just lives in someone’s head. Here’s ours.
We don’t tell half-truths or build misleading narratives. We don’t take black-hat shortcuts to game the platforms. We don’t delete criticism (as much as we’d sometimes like to) or try to sneak around it. And we don’t sell isolated vanity metrics, even when clients ask for them. (And trust me, they ask.)
That stop list has cost us. Years ago, I walked away from an extraordinarily lucrative opportunity after we’d already negotiated the terms and were about to sign the contract. Once we got into the contract, there were things they wanted us to do that weren’t outright lies, but they sat right on the squishy grey line of ethics. When I pushed back, I was told that’s just how it’s done in that industry.
I had to have a hard talk with myself, and then with my team. We couldn’t run a blog called Spin Sucks and let it slide. So we walked. It was painful, and honestly, it still stings a little. But that’s what a stop list is for.
Call it a stop list or a red flag list—whatever works for you. Just be really specific about it, and make sure everyone inside the organization knows what’s on it. It’s one of the clearest ways to describe your culture, to your team and to everyone else.
What We’ve Seen That Nobody Else Has
Funny enough, the last item on our stop list is vanity metrics, which is also where the next part of our culture starts. When you’ve sat across the table from as many teams as we have, you start to see the same things over and over again.
That’s our original data. More than 260 teams have taken the PESO Model Diagnostic since April, and across our trainings and certifications, the same patterns keep showing up.
Every team thinks it’s integrated. The evidence almost always shows it’s coordinated, not integrated.
(There’s a gigantic difference. Most teams are coordinated. Very few are integrated.)
In the Diagnostic, nearly half the teams who say they run their marketing and communications as a system score low on actual integration.
Almost nobody measures effectively. Almost everyone measures activities. Close to half of Diagnostic takers score a flat zero on one of our two measurement questions.
Because almost everyone is scared of measurement.
And almost everyone rates itself higher on the PESO Model maturity ladder than it deserves. Only 4% of the teams who’ve taken the Diagnostic land at the top of it.
And 20 years of blogging every week taught us things, too: how to write better, what resonates with big audiences, how to show up in Google first and now in AI, how to stay ethical in a world of fake news, and what thought leadership actually looks like.
(Spoiler: it’s not 25 years in an author bio.)
Why It Matters
Almost all of our clients come from our thought leadership, our content, or seeing me speak. Our culture is our sales team.
The data backs that up, too. Orbit found that publishing original research makes strong results 50% more likely—and yet fewer marketers publish it now than a few years ago.
Cyrus Shepard noted in the report that this makes no sense, since Google and AI engines have shifted to preferring exactly that kind of content.
I couldn’t agree more.
Last week, I told you about a client in a regulated industry. When we tested the questions their customers actually ask, the only content AI cited consistently was original research.
Not news releases. Not volume. Original research.
And here’s the part that made me sit back in my chair. I asked AI where the name “Spin Sucks” came from and what “Spin Sucks” refuses to do. It came back with the FADS story and our stop list.
Twenty years of saying the same things, consistently, in public, is why AI can tell our story for us.
That’s culture becoming AI visibility.
Let AI Draft. Then Add the Three Things.
OK, so what do you do with all of this on Monday morning?
It’s not fancy. Let AI write the first draft. It’s good at that, and you should absolutely use it.
Then add your people. Get one expert’s quote or story into every piece—someone inside your organization or someone your audience already trusts.
Then add your process. Name your method. If you have a framework, a set of steps, or a way of working that’s yours, say so and show your work. If you don’t, talk about the process you use internally (that isn’t proprietary, of course). The kinds of things that make you unique.
Then add your culture. Your data, your point of view, your stop list. The stuff you’ve seen that nobody else has.
And before you hit publish, ask yourself one question, “Could a competitor publish this with their logo on it?”
If the answer is yes—or even maybe—it’s not finished yet.
Is This You?
- Your blog posts don’t name a single person who works at your company. (Bylined by “admin” or “staff” counts.)
- Your author bio does all the heavy lifting on experience.
- You haven’t published original data since before you started using AI—or ever.
- Your AI drafts go from ChatGPT to the CMS, with a spell check in between.
- You can’t name one thing your company refuses to do.
If you nodded at more than two of those, you’re in very good (and very large) company. But you also have some work to do. The good news is every one of those is fixable.
Everyone Has the Same AI
Here’s what I’ve learned after watching many teams try to fix this on their own: they almost always have the experience. It just never makes it into their content. The experts are there. The method is there. The data is sitting in someone’s CRM or in a spreadsheet nobody has opened in a year.
That’s not where it breaks.
It breaks because nobody owns pulling it out of people’s heads. The AI draft goes out because it’s Tuesday and the content calendar says it’s due. Nothing connects it to earned media, so even the good stuff sits on the blog and goes nowhere. And nobody measures whether it moved the business—or changed how AI describes the company.
That’s not a writing problem. It’s not a content problem. It’s not a publishing problem. It’s a PESO Model problem.
How We Help Teams Find What Only They Have
When we work with teams, the first thing we do is find what only they have: the experts, the method, and the data hiding in plain sight. Then we build the system that gets it into owned and earned media and measures whether AI notices.
If your content could have come from anyone, I’d love to hear where you’re stuck.
Not sure where you stand? Take the PESO Model® Diagnostic. It’s free, it’s scored, and you can take it as often as you’d like.
So, Vince, is adding people, process, and culture to your content a Gini-ism? I still don’t know. But I do know AI can’t write it for you.
© 2026 Spin Sucks. All rights reserved. The PESO Model is a registered trademark of Spin Sucks.