Lindsay Bell

Five Simple Steps to a Classic PR Disaster

By: Lindsay Bell | January 16, 2013 | 
51

Today’s guest post is by Lindsay Bell

Allow me to introduce to you The City of Hamilton, Ontario and its partner in PR apocalypse, Dialogue Partners.

Hamilton started out as bucolic rolling farmland tucked in and around the Niagara Escarpment, purchased after the War of 1812.

Today it’s a bustling metropolis of just more than a half million residents, give or take a few, and sits on the west end of Lake Ontario, an area know as the Golden Horseshoe.

But don’t let all those pretty names fool you – this is a heavily industrialized port city, and is populated by proud and feisty folk who don’t take kindly to smack talk about their little piece of Ontario.

Trust me.

They don’t call it The Hammer for nothing.

And the hammer’s coming down hard at the moment. Aimed directly at the local government and the aforementioned Ottawa-based firm, Dialogue Partners.

Without boring you with the politics, the City of Hamilton decided to spend a fair chunk of taxpayer’s money – $376,000 – on a campaign called, ‘Our Voice. Our Hamilton.’ It hasn’t gone very well, to say the least. But it is a valuable learning experience. I’ve broken the whole thing down, and present you with five steps to a classic PR disaster.

Step #1 – Flawed Pre-Planning

The goal was laudable: Engage Hamiltonians in a discussion about the future of municipal services, and other such stuff. You know, stuff like public transit, garbage removal, and snow plowing. Things that *really* get a taxpayer’s dander up.

The problem started when The City of Hamilton hired a firm based in another city to build and launch the campaign.

Step #2 – Rookie Mistakes

Word got out Dialogue Partners is based in Ottawa, which is about a four hour drive, by car, from Hamilton. That alone doesn’t have to be a problem. Presumably they were the best group for the job, yes? But then they started to make mistakes. Big ones.

They launched a Hamilton Pinterest page and filled it with images that, as one poster said “….were downright insulting to this city…”. Images allegedly from Hamilton, OH and Hamilton, WA. **Not to mention a photo of a lovely bike path. A bike path in Ottawa. And on Twitter, they made the rather unfortunate error of asking one citizen what an acronym he used stood for. The acronym was for the Hamilton public transit system.

Their own website says this, “We help organizations manage public outrage, improve public participation, and foster community engagement on sensitive issues.”

Cue Step #3.

Step #3 – Inflame Public Outrage

To say Hamiltonians were outraged is an understatement.

Angry Facebook comments flew, “Fix Hamilton by spending our money somewhere else, what is wrong with these people. SHAME on anyone who had a say in this!” And Twitter was on fire:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Snarky @replies were probably the worst thing the company could have done. It’s pretty clear, with a quick glance of the Twitter stream, people were not in the mood for nudge nudge wink wink.

Soon the hashtag “#tellOHeverything” was trending in Canada. Used to poke a sharp stick at the Ottawa-based campaign, it “explained” with hilarious results Hamilton sites and landmarks, such as, “Cannon street is best known for firing cars very fast in a single direction.” And “@KingandJames and “Cootes’ Paradise is a local wetland, not a poorly-named old folks’ home.”

Then the local media came calling.

Step #4 – Use Other Media to Make Light of Said PR Disaster

Hamilton’s no cowtown. It’s roughly the size of Boston and has a highly engaged social community. In fact, many quality local digital marketers and advertising firms were unhappily scratching their heads, saying they hadn’t even known the original request for tender was on the table. Word was getting around.

By day two, the whole mess had hit the papers and other news sites, and the managing director of Dialogue Partners made what might have been the biggest mistake yet. She played it down. Poo-poo’ed those few outraged social media types. And instead of apologizing for the blunders that were made, she set about spinning them (for shame!).

One local councillor even joked that, hey, at least they created awareness, and lots of it, in only 24 hours!

I think that’s about when the #Vote2014 tweets started flying.

Step #5 – Finally Make a Half-Hearted Apology While Shifting the Blame

Boom went the dynamite. Hamiltonians were more enraged than ever. And on day three, Dialogue finally posted an apology – a really long apology – on their Facebook page (which has now been taken down).

Except it wasn’t really an apology. It was, in the words of one Facebook fan, it was a, “We’re really sorry you caught us.”

They described their contract, and talked a bit about their firm. They told the community that someone attempted to hack their website (see apology letter link below), and implied that the incorrect Pinterest pictures were posted by other people.

They apologized for the way the conversation flowed on Twitter (which was odd, as it was the irate citizens themselves driving that conversation). And to end, they did admit that the first 24 hours of their campaign wasn’t what they had hoped it would be.

Ain’t that the truth.

So there you have it. Five easy steps to a pretty good PR disaster. There’s now chatter the City *might break their contract with Dialogue, which will be a huge waste of taxpayers dollars. And something that probably doesn’t need to happen, if only they had arrived in Hammertown better prepared – and had dealt with the ensuing outrage when they didn’t – with a little more grace and aplomb.

Now do me a favor, ok? Keep writing those PR/Marketing/Social Media 101 posts. Because there are a lot of people out there who still need them.

*NOTE: As of January 15th, Hamilton councillors gave city staff just over a week to continue negotiations with Dialogue Partners, who have released an apology letter to the citizens of Hamilton. Barn door/horse comes to mind.

**UPDATE: It’s been brought to my attention that the media reports around the picture of the bike path were incorrect. The image is in fact a bike path that is located in Hamilton.

Lindsay Bell is the content director at Arment Dietrich, and works in Toronto. A former TV producer, she’s a strong advocate of three minutes or less of video content. She has a cool kid, a patient husband, and two annoying cats. 

About Lindsay Bell


Lindsay Bell is the content director at V3 Marketing, and works in Toronto. A former TV producer, she’s a strong advocate of three minutes or less of video content. She has a cool kid, a patient husband, two annoying cats, and Hank Dawge, a Vizsla/Foxhound/moose hybrid. Ok, maybe not moose.

Spin Sucks in Your Inbox

Leave a Reply

51 Comments on "Five Simple Steps to a Classic PR Disaster"

avatar

Sort by:   newest | oldest
coffeewithjulie
coffeewithjulie
3 years 6 months ago

Oh, how did I miss this one? Oh well, I enjoyed your summary much more than living through it live I think!

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@coffeewithjulie Ha! Thanks Julie. Many lessons to be learned with this cock-up!

KenMueller
3 years 6 months ago

Wow. Sounds like something out of a script from Parks & Recreation….

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@KenMueller What’s the classic line Ken? You can’t make this stuff up! But replace “stuff” with a swear. 😉

AmyMccTobin
3 years 6 months ago

Please tell me they were fired and refunded Hamilton the money.  That’s just like all PR disasters – lacking any common sense. WOW.

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@AmyMccTobin Nope, I added an update to the bottom of the post Amy, they have been given another week’s reprieve, so that more conversations around the matter can happen. Which again is just crazy. Either the City of Hamilton should stand up and back them, or stand up and fire them.

AmyMccTobin
3 years 6 months ago

@belllindsay Wow again. No question, fire them.

RebeccaTodd
3 years 6 months ago

WOW! What a debacle. People not taking ownership for their actions may be the single most irritating trait anyone can show in my eyes. And I know you know how I feel about tossing snaky tweets out…never, never, NEVER the right move.  If you have to add “just joking” or “ell oh ell” or “winky face” to be sure that everyone will get your “joke”, don’t do it!

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@RebeccaTodd Exactly!! Then to back pedal, and (allegedly) put the blame for some of the errors on the general public…??? Wow. Next, they’ll be saying that Anonymous hacked them. 🙂

RebeccaTodd
3 years 6 months ago

@belllindsay When a business “blames” the customers, I do not trust that they will not blame me in the future. Is it bad that I want to tell her to grow a pair?

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@RebeccaTodd I imagine that she is getting ‘direction from above’….but I agree.

ExtremelyAvg
3 years 6 months ago

I feel badly for the people of Hamilton. I’m glad they stood up and unleashed a social media storm on the poorly planned campaign. That is the beauty of this day and age, the lowly masses have a voice…a really loud tweety voice!
 
Go Hamilton Go!!! You are my new favorite city in Canada.

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@ExtremelyAvg “a really loud tweety voice” HA! Love it!! As I mentioned, Hamilton has a *very* active and vocal social media community. It truly was embarrassing.

allenmireles
3 years 6 months ago

@belllindsay  @ExtremelyAvg I am SO stealing “really loud tweety voice”!

ExtremelyAvg
3 years 6 months ago

@allenmireles  @belllindsay Nothing would make me happier than to have someone take joy in using one of my phrases.

bdorman264
3 years 6 months ago

Hammer down in Hammertown; classic.
 
Even better, they could have used a US firm, huh?
 
And I thought the Canucks were easy going; start messing w/ their tax dollars and it’s like poking a hornets nest, si?

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@bdorman264 You don’t mess with the Hammer. But seriously, what a mess. And what was the company thinking being so (apparently) unprepared!? Many, many lessons learned with this one.

TonyBennett
3 years 6 months ago

Wow, they must have read the book Instagram published about PR… but instead of backing down, they just threw some fuel on the fire.  What.A.Mess.
 
In other enws, I’m also excited that you used the term escarpment, I’m a closet geological slappy so that got me pretty pumped up.  I’m going to go read about glaciers some more 🙂

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@TonyBennett Mess might be an understatement. I’ve already heard from a couple of hamilton peeps who are beyond PO’ed. Good for them.
 
I’m a total science geek. I watch docs about how the earth was formed and other such geekery. I love the Niagara Escarpment. 😉

ExtremelyAvg
3 years 6 months ago

@belllindsay  @TonyBennett I didn’t know that word. I looked it up and feel all warm and fuzzy about the new word added to my vocabulary.

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@ExtremelyAvg  @TonyBennett YAY! I love words so much.

allenmireles
3 years 6 months ago

Oh my goodness, @belllindsay  How ever did I miss this? Oh, right. I know. I had my head down and was working, yeah, that’s it! I love the way you break this down and make it simple for anyone to relate to. Anyone. Funny how common sense so often plays no part in this stuff!

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@allenmireles I know!! You don’t have to be some kind of PR guru to figure out these steps. It’s how one functions in life! Or, you would hope. 😉

AmyMccTobin
3 years 6 months ago

You know what makes me ANGRY?  That I know so many excellent marketing and pr specialists who struggle to get clients and would LOVE a job like this!!!!!  HOW on earth do these folks land this gig? It CAN’T be on their track record.

ExtremelyAvg
3 years 6 months ago

@AmyMccTobin I suspect there may be an opening to take over the campaign. You should let your friends know about it. That would be awesome if one of them got the gig.

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@ExtremelyAvg  @AmyMccTobin Sheeesh. Can we at least keep it in Canada! 😉

jasondyk
jasondyk
3 years 6 months ago

This is a great breakdown Lindsay! It’s amazing what could happen if people actually preplanned stuff and took a second to think….”What could possibly go wrong?” I think if they stopped to think about it for a second they likely wouldn’t have gone about it the way they did…or hopefully at least did a little more research 🙂

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@jasondyk Yeah, one would think that thinking would be Step 1 in anyone’s plan. LOL!! And thanks so much for tipping me off to this story last week Jason!!

jasondyk
jasondyk
3 years 6 months ago

@belllindsay my pleasure! I’ll put it on your tab 🙂

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@jasondyk LOL!!

DonnaPapacosta
3 years 6 months ago

Excellent write-up of this sorry situation. Thanks for sharing.

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@DonnaPapacosta Thanks Donna. Quite a fiasco, no? Will be interesting to follow and see how it all plays out! 🙂

dwaynealicie
3 years 6 months ago

Oh my — definitely a mess. And a wonderful analysis of it here! I appreciate how you bring it all back around with a call to action to keep conversations going about the basics of PR/Marketing/Social Media.  This story indeed serves as a reminder that the ability to point, click and type does not necessarily make a competent practitioner; talent and skill are still required. And it’s very clear when they are missing!

belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@dwaynealicie Thanks so much Dwayne. I think it behooves those who are at the top (of any field) to continue to share tips and tidbits about how they got there – no matter how basic! There are always new people entering a field, and hey, everyone’s got to learn! But you don’t want to learn from mistakes as egregious as this one was!!  Cheers, LB

AlistairJamesMorton
AlistairJamesMorton
3 years 6 months ago
I think their biggest fault was launching simply as a twitter account.   Be in the city, be in front of the local cameras, be in the press, tell people what to look for, give them a human face or faces to the campaign. Actually spend a few bucks on a website and brand, test it for user feedback and soft launch it to test out your code so no nasty payday loan hacks get in for launch.   If you feel you are losing the community, DO NOT STOP TALKING. They turned off the lights about 16 hours after launch… Read more »
belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago

@AlistairJamesMorton Hi Alistair, thanks for dropping by. “I annoy half my twitter followers every week, they stick with me because I continue to engage with them.” – That made me laugh out loud. 🙂 And you’re so right. They dropped a very salvageable ball, kicked it into touch, then set about making rookie mistake after rookie mistake. It really was a textbook example of what not to do. And ‘standing O’ to Hamiltonians for taking them to task on it. Cheers, LB

HamOntReporter
HamOntReporter
3 years 6 months ago
You are wrong Ms.Lindsay… your SPIN sucks!! What happened here is more than an overreach of a small town echo chamber. Here is how this ‘trivialization’ got started by an individual with his explicit public call to “swarm” Dialogue Partners via twitter. There was no thought to the legal consequences of inciting such directed public action. Without allowing Dialogue Partners time to offer an explanation, the inciter acted as the arbiter of DP’s website design, and went on to act as the “Judge, Jury and the Executioner” of whom he considered had grossly wronged the entire city of Hamilton. And… Read more »
ginidietrich
3 years 6 months ago

@HamOntReporter I am the owner of this blog and one of our policies state we have fair and professional discourse. Your first sentence leads me to believe that is not your intent and, because you are posting without a name and under the auspice of “Hamilton Reporter,” my inclination is to remove your comments. I am leaving this one because it was the most tame of the three, but the other two have been deleted for defamation of character and unfair – and anonymous – mudslinging toward one of our guest authors.

AmyMccTobin
3 years 6 months ago

@ginidietrich  @HamOntReporter I read your responses in my email delivery of Spin Sucks HamOntReporter and my only answer is: I hope you don’t actually work for Dialogue Partners, but I suspect you do.  The first answer to a PR debacle is to NOT go on the attack.  A sincere apology where appropriate, and an honest and open conversation about what happened is the answer.  You are a) Anonymous, and b) ranting at fever pitch.  A PR professional could really help you know.

HamOntReporter
HamOntReporter
3 years 6 months ago
ginidietrich, AmyMccTobin: My apologies if you feel my comments are a rant. I was just mirroring the title and tone of this blog in my first line. I do not work for DP, nor am I in the PR industry. A simple Google search would have told you who I am — (interestingly those who joined in the lynching also told that DP should have just googled HSR!! and then concluded that DP did not have a clue of what they were doing!! :)…  Don’t you think you have been unfair and defamed character with your story – when it… Read more »
belllindsay
belllindsay
3 years 6 months ago
@HamOntReporter Based on your tone, as well as the previous comments you made on this site (which as Gini mentions below, were taken down due to their rather inflammatory content), in the end I was hoping that at best you and I could “agree to disagree” on this whole affair. However, with this last comment I must respond. I will not allow anyone to call into question my character or – more importantly – my journalistic integrity. I have spent the last 20+ years as a researcher, writer, producer and story teller, in various media. I’m quite adept at using Google,… Read more »
HamOntReporter
HamOntReporter
3 years 6 months ago
@belllindsay  Civilized conversations can only happen when one stops being so defensive and moralistic when one is called out for being slanderous and ill-informed. This is where your moral and ethical journalist compass went awry: “The problem started when The City of Hamilton hired a firm based in another city to build and launch the campaign.”  What you are telling your readers is that the “culprit” was the consultant company — even before you have presented a prosecution worthy case. There was no problem well into 60% of the contracted work, up until part of the community engagement piece to… Read more »
HamOntReporter
HamOntReporter
3 years 6 months ago
@belllindsay  Here is a RE TWEET by the very same man – from two days ago — an elected councillor of the City of Hamilton – who has been one of the central Tweeters to spread the flames of hatred against the consultants – someone to whom research and facts are immaterial to the “game” : 20 Jan …. Even PR Daily has heard of #HamOnt’s PR campaign gone so, SO wrong! #OurHamilton http://www.prdaily.com/Main/Articles/13623.aspx# … [[ “Retweeted by Sam Merulla” ]] What you call a “PR apocalypse” was nothing more than a well orchestrated  public lynching. I hope someday, you do… Read more »
AmyMccTobin
3 years 6 months ago

@HamOntReporter  @belllindsay As a non involved observer here is my question:  Is this blog post not accurate in its dissection of how Dialogue Partners responded to the uproar, orchestrated or not????   <— that is the entire point of dissecting what happened.  As PR and Marketing professionals we learn from these occurrences.  If indeed Dialogue Partners responded with snark, took down their exploding FB page etc., they should be fired for their reaction to the firestorm.  After all, aren’t they PR Professionals themselves??Crises occur regularly; companies/cities/organizations hire outside consultants to guide them through them, not inflame them.

HamOntReporter
HamOntReporter
3 years 6 months ago
trackback

[…] Tone and Intent. How many times have you heard an apology and felt it was forced, almost as if someone was saying, “Now, say you’re sorry,” not […]

trackback

[…] For a look at what not to do during a crisis, read last week’s post on 3 crisis communications mistakes to avoid, and check out this story on how the City of Hamilton ended up in a PR disaster. […]

trackback

[…] – Five Simple Steps to a Classic PR Disaster. Really, what more is there to say? Well how about number two goes to yours truly!? Yup, on […]

Juliwilson789
Juliwilson789
1 year 2 months ago

Great
tips and very easy to understand. This will definitely be very useful for me
when I get a chance to start my blog. Thanks for sharing such a great content
with us. 
http://www.chautauqualakeboatrentals.com

codyerin
codyerin
1 year 2 months ago

Excellent
share, this is a really quality post. In underlying objects theory I’d like
to write like this too. Taking time and real effort to make a good article.http://www.koratrealestate.org

codyerin
codyerin
1 year 2 months ago

You need
to take part in a contest for one of the finest websites online. I’m going to
recommend this web site!
http://www.tricouhouse.com

wpDiscuz
[postmatic_subscribe_widget]