Gini Dietrich

Ketchum and the Putin OpEd Create Disclosure in Media Relations Debate

By: Gini Dietrich | September 26, 2013 | 
69

Ketchum and the Putin OpEd Create Disclosure in Media Relations DebateBy Gini Dietrich

In early 2009, the Halifax-Plympton Reporter received a letter to the editor urging, “People contact their Congressman about the Medicare Advantage program, a sort of privatized health plan paid for through the recipient’s Medicare. There may be some interest in doing away with the program.”

Seems benign enough, right? The letter was signed by a local resident, but it didn’t mention the local Congressman who people should contact, which the paper’s editor found strange. So he called the man whose signature was on the letter and was surprised to learn he had no idea what he was talking about.

The editor filed the letter and went on about his day.

About a week later, he received a phone call from a man who said he was calling on behalf of the person who wrote the letter. The editor told the caller what he had done and asked who he was and who he worked for. He declined to tell the editor who he was and hung up the phone.

But what the caller didn’t count on was caller ID.

The editor traced the caller back to a high-powered lobbying and public affairs firm. It became pretty evident the firm was working for an organization with an interest in keeping Medicare Advantage in business…and were creating letters to the editors in the names of people in the Congressional District without their knowledge.

Spin Certainly Sucks

This isn’t uncommon. A couple of years ago, Burson-Marsteller was caught in a whisper campaign. They were creating negative stories about Google on behalf of Facebook and journalists nearly had a fit.

The PR industry is not notorious for its ethics. In fact, because of the reputation, this blog is called Spin Sucks.

It’s pretty disappointing when people in our profession not only do unethical things, but get caught doing them and we all suffer.

But where do we draw the line?

Work with Foreign Governments

Fast forward to two weeks ago when President Putin wrote an OpEd that ran in the New York Times. It quickly came out that Ketchum, a large and highly respected PR firm, placed the editorial, just a day after President Obama made his speech regarding Syria.

Ketchum has long worked for the Russian government, placing stories and interviews for Putin in American publications for several years.

There isn’t anything wrong with working with foreign governments as long as the companies provide detailed reports of their activities to the U.S. government.

Foreign governments tend to be substantial business for the larger, global firms and, when handled correctly, help advance human rights and world peace. That is good.

What’s not good is when the PR firms use their work with foreign governments to fake stories, create non-existent opportunities, and dismiss the facts.

Case in point: The same PR firm also places editorials by “seemingly independent professionals” that praise Russia in outlets such as CNBC and the Huffington Post, according to ProPublica.

The site goes on to detail the pieces that were written and by whom, but chides agencies – and media outlets – for not disclosing how the opinion pieces ended up there in the first place. A disclosure that would say something along the lines of, “A representative from Ketchum contacted us and placed this OpEd in our publication.”

Disclosure in Media Relations

I wonder, again, where we draw the line?

Media relations is the backbone of a strong communications program. There are many relationships we have at Arment Dietrich that we created on behalf of our clients and continue them for the benefit of current and future clients.

Journalists and bloggers know we have a business reason to be contacting them and they know, when pitching an editorial or a story, we’re doing so on behalf of a client.

Should we have to say, in every email or phone call or text, “This is on behalf of XYZ client,” particularly if we work with them a lot for that client or it’s clear who we’re pitching?

And should the media have to disclose the relationship with us when running the story?

I suppose, in an age of transparency, it makes sense for the media to disclose the relationship when printing the story. I wonder, then, how many stories in the paper or on the news will have those disclosures? I’d venture to guess more than half, even closer to 70 or 80 percent.

I don’t have the right answer, but what I do know is this: Astroturfing, whisper campaigns, and making up people to write editorials on behalf of your clients is bad. I’d even go so far as to say placing an OpEd in an American publication from a man who has no interest in working with our government is bad.

But I do understand why it’s done and, just like cigarettes and big oil, there are some organizations who will do the work. But why should we all suffer?

About Gini Dietrich


Gini Dietrich is the founder and CEO of Arment Dietrich, an integrated marketing communications firm. She is the author of Spin Sucks, co-author of Marketing in the Round, and co-host of Inside PR. She also is the lead blogger at Spin Sucks and is the founder of Spin Sucks Pro.

Spin Sucks in Your Inbox

Leave a Reply

69 Comments on "Ketchum and the Putin OpEd Create Disclosure in Media Relations Debate"

avatar

Sort by:   newest | oldest
ginidietrich
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

lzone I agree with your “hmmm…” I can’t decide where the line is drawn.

lzone
lzone
2 years 7 months ago

ginidietrich very interesting debate. Thanks for sharing.

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

lzone I started out to write it about the OpEd and then kept reading and it changed course.

lzone
lzone
2 years 7 months ago

ginidietrich FTR, I’m proud to work at a firm with strong ethics. Sounds like you are too. :)

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

lzone I am! We would never do that kind of work…even for $23 million.

LauraPetrolino
2 years 7 months ago
oohhhhh @ginidietrich you are just adding to my awesome mood today with this article! Stuff like this gets me all fired up and academic-like. As a communications professional, who was a poly sci major, and started her career working in politics, these issues are things I constantly have arguments (with myself, and my dog, and sometimes my cat, but he’s a communist so really isn’t helpful in these discussions) about.  I think very few people really grasp the level of extremely strategic communications and media placement that make up the political landscape we know today. Sure, people get how it impacts campaigns… Read more »
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

LauraPetrolino I know this has always been done in politics and around the movie awards (lots of whisper campaigns).  I have a chapter dedicated to it in Spin Sucks. Where I struggle is where the ethics line lies. Should media disclose every time they work with a PR pro? Is this different than getting paid to write about something? I think it is, but maybe the transparency lines make it the same. 
I also know people are up in arms about Ketchum working with Russia on this. They’re calling them unethical. I’m not so sure that’s the case.

LauraPetrolino
2 years 7 months ago

Yep ….very much agreed. It’s so many pros and cons depending on where tha disclosure line is drawn. Hence why this is such an interesting discussion to have.

DanielleGross
DanielleGross
2 years 7 months ago

ginidietrich LauraPetrolino in PA, you’re supposed to register as a lobbyist with the state if you’re doing this kind of work – they call it “indirect lobbying.” My firm complies – but we’re a lobbying/PR hybrid. I think a lot of PR firms in my region who do the same kind of work fail to register completely and aren’t worried about the fallout.  
I believe there are similar rules and regs for efforts at the federal level.

ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

DanielleGross LauraPetrolino This is part of the problem with the industry. Why wouldn’t they register? What do they have to hide? It’s organizations like that that make the rest of us look bad.

jasonkonopinski
2 years 7 months ago

Hmmm. I need to think on this one a bit further.

ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

jasonkonopinski I’ve thought about it for two weeks and I’m still not sure of the right answer.

SpinSucks
SpinSucks
2 years 7 months ago

wbsmith200 Hi Bill!

wbsmith200
wbsmith200
2 years 7 months ago

SpinSucks How’s it going? I loved that piece and look forward to Gini’s talk to the digital foundations class at #digitaledu.

SpinSucks
SpinSucks
2 years 7 months ago

wbsmith200 It’s good, thanks!! Hope all is well with you too :) ginidietrich always delivers a good talk!

wbsmith200
wbsmith200
2 years 7 months ago

SpinSucks I heard ginidietrich speak at Third Tuesday Toronto a couple years back supporting her book Marketing in the Round.

SpinSucks
SpinSucks
2 years 7 months ago

wbsmith200 ginidietrich Nice! First time I saw her speak was at #PRSA – but I was too shy to say hello….

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

SpinSucks HAHAHAH! You were too shy to say hello. LOL!

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

wbsmith200 Are you in Martin’s class? Or Eden’s?

wbsmith200
wbsmith200
2 years 7 months ago

ginidietrich I’m in Eden’s class.

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

wbsmith200 Ah ha! I’ll see you in a couple of weeks, then.

wbsmith200
wbsmith200
2 years 7 months ago

ginidietrich I’m looking forward to that class. In the meantime I have to click on that SEO Webinar link.

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

wbsmith200 Ah! We’re hosting right now, but you can always register and have the recording sent to you.

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

wbsmith200 Oh you made it!

wbsmith200
wbsmith200
2 years 7 months ago

ginidietrich I did. I like crestodina as a speaker so far.

SpinSucks
SpinSucks
2 years 7 months ago

ginidietrich How did I not see this yesterday?! Um, yeah…I was like “Oh, maybe next time”

SpinSucks
SpinSucks
2 years 7 months ago

lkpetrolino #petropower

lkpetrolino
lkpetrolino
2 years 7 months ago

SpinSucks :-) :-) :-)

lkpetrolino
lkpetrolino
2 years 7 months ago

SpinSucks and a happy Friday Jr. to you ma’am!

SpinSucks
SpinSucks
2 years 7 months ago

lkpetrolino 😀 Thank you doll! You too!

SpinSucks
SpinSucks
2 years 7 months ago

RebeccaAmyTodd How are you feeling? Saw that you and belllindsay are both sick after your night out!

RebeccaAmyTodd
RebeccaAmyTodd
2 years 7 months ago

SpinSucks belllindsay yes! She got me sick, I swear it.

SpinSucks
SpinSucks
2 years 7 months ago

RebeccaAmyTodd belllindsay I just like to blame everything on her.

belllindsay
belllindsay
2 years 7 months ago

SpinSucks RebeccaAmyTodd That’s funny. I’m blaming ginidietrich

Nuk3dawg
Nuk3dawg
2 years 7 months ago

belllindsay SpinSucks RebeccaAmyTodd ginidietrich L O L A

SpinSucks
SpinSucks
2 years 7 months ago

Janet_Tyler Thanks for the share Janet! Glad you enjoyed the post :)

ClayMorgan
2 years 7 months ago
I think there are a few issues at play. 1. In terms of the editorial from President Putin, I wonder if the New York Times was just excited to have an editorial from the president of Russia, that it didn’t stop to think about other things. 2. Does the person need to write the editorial himself? At 8:43 a.m.,  I received an email from Robert Jameson, the communications director for US Rep. Scott DesJarlais, who represents our district. He is submitting a column under the representative’s byline. Do I accept it as “his,” know that someone on his staff is… Read more »
Joshua Wilner/A Writer Writes
2 years 7 months ago

ClayMorgan Unless your average person has an internal contact or is exceptionally savvy I don’t know how they would get the space in the NYT, WSJ or most “large” papers.
 My guess is they would be referred to the letters section.

ClayMorgan
2 years 7 months ago

Joshua Wilner/A Writer Writes ClayMorgan Where, unfortunately, they are usually limited to 200 or 250 words (even in my paper).

DanielleGross
DanielleGross
2 years 7 months ago

ClayMorgan Joshua Wilner/A Writer Writes I don’t think the average person could even score a placement in a top paper in their home state, let alone a national paper. 
and ClayMorgan in my experience with state lawmakers, most do not write their own LTEs/opinion pieces. Neither do most business owners or association leaders. 

PR person here, but I don’t see an ethical problem with ghostwriting as long as the PR person discloses to the writer their client/angle, and lets them review/change the opinion piece before the signer submits the letter on his or her own.

makasha
2 years 7 months ago

DanielleGross ClayMorgan Joshua Wilner/A Writer Writes I totally agree Danielle. As a PR person, we help our clients with messaging. As long as I write the opt ed based on the client’s ideals and the client approves the piece then it falls on the good side of things. However, making up fake personas is very, very bad.

Joshua Wilner/A Writer Writes
2 years 7 months ago

DanielleGross ClayMorgan
It naturally begs the question of whether the average person should be given space and whether they merit the same as an “expert.”
 I would lean towards no.

ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

ClayMorgan So my thoughts:
1) Most organizations can’t get a story in the NYT, but I’d be wiling to guess they’d take a call from Putin’s office without the PR firm.
2) This is a good question. We write stuff for clients all the time. They review and approve it, but it does lead to the debate about ghost authoring things for executives.
3) I don’t know the right answer to that. Yes?

susancellura
susancellura
2 years 7 months ago

So much to think about. Back later…  :)

susancellura
susancellura
2 years 7 months ago
I just can’t see Brian Williams stating how NBC got a news story after every piece on the evening news. Or even having a banner run at the bottom of the screen. 1) “The site goes on to detail the pieces that were written and by whom, but chides agencies…” Is/was this just an opportunity to fling mud? Something that people do more and more often based on “transparency”? I don’t know. 2) Do papers, etc., now have to consider having footnotes and/or bibliographies for the 70-80% of the news that is printed?  3) Is this Ketchum kerfluffle a part… Read more »
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

susancellura I don’t know the right answer. I sat on this for two weeks because I’m sitting on the fence about it all. But I do know I would never pitch a story without saying who the client is. I guess THAT is the real line – when you’re doing a whisper campaign or spinning the truth, you’re less willing to share who the client is.

LouHoffman
LouHoffman
2 years 7 months ago
Gini, I agree with your broad point. But I also think it’s reasonable to hold journalists accountable for framing their stories with context.  Rewinding the tape to the Burson whisper campaign on behalf of Facebook, yes the firm should have been transparent and shared the name of the client. However, until  Christopher Soghoian posted his exchange with the BM rep on the Internet and Daily Beast blogger at the time Dan Lyons connected the dots, many journalists used the same information from BM to write their stories … without the context of knowing who was footing the bill for BM’s… Read more »
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

LouHoffman This is such an interesting debate to have. What I find most fascinating is places such as ProPublica are coming down on PR firms about this, but not on the media. I’ve never done business where a journalist doesn’t know who our client is, but then I don’t do astroturfing or whisper campaigns. Kind of amazing.

Howie Goldfarb
2 years 7 months ago

ginidietrich  LouHoffman media sells out for the story as well. Especially if it is easy gravy and some fame for the writer. but when discovered you lose credibility. Fox News easily could be credible with the same right wing view. But then Jon Stewart is out of business.
The National Enquirer proved we don’t want the truth. We pay for sensation even if it is a lie. And many news orgs make more money that way. Very sad. Blame the consumer of the media as well!

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

amvandenhurk xoxo

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

NickKalm Thanks, Nick!

NickKalm
NickKalm
2 years 7 months ago

ginidietrich Great piece!

ginidietrich
ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

TomMartin Thank you, sir.

makasha1
makasha1
2 years 7 months ago

This is a great article. While I think the whisper articles are down right wrong, I don’t know if it is possible to give disclaimers on all media placements.

ginidietrich
2 years 7 months ago

makasha It makes you really think about the PR vs. media industries. There is always so much backlash…I wonder if it’s because there are no clear cut guidelines.

clay_morgan
clay_morgan
2 years 7 months ago

ginidietrich I’m drawing the line right over THERE.

Howie Goldfarb
2 years 7 months ago

I tell you all the time I would never have shady companies like walmart or facebook as clients. I refuse to sell out for the money. What is ironic is how many men disparage women who say are strippers, yet they themselves sell out more than their body for the money.
Is Edelman shady in the ways Ketchum and Ryan Holiday and Breitbart are? Please say yes! lol

Frank_Strong
2 years 7 months ago
Sigh. Don’t hate me Gini. I read this…this morning and didn’t comment. I can’t resist now.  I’ll talk policy, then PR.  Policy:  Syria is incredibly strategic. but sadly most Americans don’t care to understand why. Syria links Iran with Hezbollah in Lebanon.  Hezbollah is classified by the State Department as a terrorist organization.  One analyst likens them to a land-based aircraft carrier sitting north of Israel.  Conventional analysis says Russia sells arms to both Syria and Iran. It’s complex, no? And we haven’t yet discussed tribes or religion or why Iran is worrisome (Hint: Nukes).  I’m a veteran.  I’ve deployed… Read more »
Howie Goldfarb
2 years 7 months ago
Frank_Strong what a great comment Frank! and thank you for your service. We assassinated the first democratically elected president in the mid-east over oil (Iran) in the 50’s. They have hated us every since. We have done horrible things as a nation over the years in the name of money, land etc. In fact we fail to accept this as a nation. From South America to how we took over our lands here. From slavery to the fact we refused to allow equal rights for another 100 years. We have supported heinous dictators in the name of stopping communism. I… Read more »
Frank_Strong
2 years 7 months ago

Howie Goldfarb  Well Howie, you are right. America is not perfect. But I’m grateful that you can express your views without fear of reprisal. And I would not fault you for hiring a PR firm to help you express your views more broadly, which is the point I think we are both making.  I’m off to read your most recent post now.

Joshua Wilner/A Writer Writes
2 years 7 months ago
Howie Goldfarb Frank_Strong I would rather see what Putin thinks when he writes in Russian than when someone crafts a piece and puts his name on it. Show me a country that doesn’t have blood on its hands. Show me a country that doesn’t have a laundry list of things to be called on the carpet for. Now show me the countries where you can publicly call the government to question and not worry about what happens afterwards. There are a bunch of them but you won’t find very men in certain parts of the world. Baby Assad isn’t doing anything… Read more »
Frank_Strong
Frank_Strong
2 years 7 months ago

LouHoffman my big mouth? It is just an incredibly complicated situation.

LouHoffman
LouHoffman
2 years 7 months ago

Frank_Strong The Mid East is complicated. The issue of journalists being accountable for “story context” seems straight forward to me.

Frank_Strong
2 years 7 months ago

@LouHoffman Yikes!  I don’t like that my Tweet is sucked into these comments!

LynnMcConaughey
LynnMcConaughey
2 years 7 months ago
Gini, I was interested to see the direction you went with this issue, and it was unexpected that you focused on the disclosure aspect. I was more upset by the treatment the op-ed received from NPR’s “The World” than with the transaction itself. I think transparency by PR and strategic communications companies is essential to help break the media of its mantra that influence is inappropriate. Even a simple, “factual” press release is an effort to influence a customer or audience in some way. Working as I have with the US government and defense department, I am part of the… Read more »
LouHoffman
LouHoffman
2 years 7 months ago
LynnMcConaugheyThe question of morality in regards to an agency taking on a client is a tough one. As you put it, these things are rarely “black and white.” One could argue that even Russia falls into the gray area. We ran into a situation earlier in the year when an online company that facilitates infidelity approached our Asia Pacific team for PR support. Our AP head called me to say the management team had decided to take a pass. A check around the region showed no one was comfortable working for this company. That’s not a bad litmus test. If… Read more »
trackback

[…] PR podcast, Martin Waxman, Gini Dietrich and Joseph Thornley tackle an issue raised byGini in a post on Spin Sucks: disclosure by PR agencies of business interest in media relations pitches. Gini kicks off the […]

trackback

[…] unless it’s clearly disclosed. And, ProPublica just came out against the New York Times for not disclosing who helped them with the President Putin editorial (hint: It was […]

nimiparker
nimiparker
11 months 15 days ago

I really
enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that
you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post http://www.gottocollegevt.org

wpDiscuz
[postmatic_subscribe_widget]