Gini Dietrich

The Chick-fil-A PR Crisis

By: Gini Dietrich | July 26, 2012 | 

I’ve been in Canada all week, in meetings with clients, sitting in new business meetings with our Thornley Fallis colleagues, and speaking at Third Tuesday (and at SocialMix today). So I haven’t been able to keep up on the news as much as I typically do.

So when the Chick-fil-A fiasco hit my inbox earlier this week, I made a mental note to make sure I got back to it when I got home.

But then I learned they were creating fake Facebook accounts to tell their story and I knew it couldn’t wait.

The Background

For those of you who haven’t yet heard what’s going on, the story goes like this.

On July 18, Chick-fil-A president and COO, Dan Cathy told the Baptist Press the company opposes same-sex marriage. His direct quote:

We are very much supportive of the family — the biblical definition of the family unit. We are a family-owned business, a family-led business, and we are married to our first wives. We give God thanks for that.

Of course that’s bad  enough in our day where parts of our population are not supported in certain areas (including Sally Ride and her partner, Tam O’Shaughnessy, who spent 27 years together).

Boston’s Mayor issued a statement saying Chick-fil-A is not welcome in the city. And our own Chicago’s Mayor echoed his sentiments.

And Then

Jim Henson’s company decided to sever its business relationship with the fast food company. The company released a statement saying it supports diversity and inclusiveness. It also said the company is using the payment it received from Chick-fil-A, for Henson toys in kid’s meals, to the Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation.

That didn’t sit very well with Chick-fil-A, which issued a statement saying the toys had been taken out of stores because of safety issues, not because Henson’s company publicly severed the relationship.

But that’s not all!

The statement wasn’t enough. They then took to Facebook to defend the decision by creating fake Facebook accounts.

Yes, you heard me right. They created fake Facebook accounts, particularly of one Ms. Abby Farle, who was on the company’s page defending their decision.

Because the comments seemed odd and by someone people on the page hadn’t seen before (and because you can clearly see she’s lying, based on the image you see above), they flagged the comments (talk about self-policing!).

What they found is the account had been created only eight hours earlier and Abby’s avatar is a stock photo of a pretty young redhead.

The PR Lesson

It’s one thing to take a stance on your beliefs. Chick-fil-A has long been closed on Sundays, not changing their policy even after malls began opening on the Sabbath. And, yes, we live in a free country so it’s their prerogative to support – or not – all Americans.

But creating fake Facebook accounts and lying about why toys have been pulled from their meals?

There is no room for it. Maybe they could have gotten away with it before social media and the age of transparency. Perhaps there would have been a small media war between the two companies – a he said/she said story.

But the people wouldn’t have been able to quickly discover we were being duped.

Social media provides an amazing opportunity to connect and engage with your customers – the happy and unhappy ones. But when you alienate people, lie, and create fake accounts to defend your position, you’re going to be found out.

Behaving this way doesn’t seem very Christian to me.

Update: Chick-fil-A released a statement saying they did not create the two Facebook accounts (one was deleted and the other was outed, as you see above).

About Gini Dietrich

Gini Dietrich is the founder and CEO of Arment Dietrich, an integrated marketing communications firm. She is the author of Spin Sucks, co-author of Marketing in the Round, and co-host of Inside PR. She also is the lead blogger at Spin Sucks and is the founder of Spin Sucks Pro.



  1. […] practitioners have gotten, get and will always earn a bad rap; especially if they’re behind the Chick Fil-A debacle, PR crisis. If you’ve been following any posts here, at Spin Sucks, at Waxing Unlyrical or at Danny […]

  2. […] Every blogger has been enraptured with the PR debacle of Chick fil-A. As is my wont, I am not the first mover when it comes to new apps, channels, or breaking news (well, I do sometimes break a story). I let the other guys pave my way, and oh boy, did Gini Dietrich’s blog do a yeoman’s job.  […]

  3. […] two fake Facebook accounts, using stock photography. Again, they got caught red handed, however Chick-fil-A stands by they were not behind these accounts.  There’s no pulling the wool over the public’s eyes in the age of transparency.  Then in a […]

  4. […] Social Media will continue to be the people’s voice. Expect more Brands to suffer from missteps that cause uproars with most failing with their responses. While at the same time Brands will rarely experience the […]

  5. […] decided to sever its relationship with Chick-fil-A because of its stance on same-sex marriage.[4]  This compounded Chick-fil-A’s PR problem and some believe that the company then created a […]

  6. […] no surprise the bad case studies are shared over and over and over again. When Chick-fil-A had their train wreck of an issue because their CEO came out against the gay and lesbian community, the best content was about why […]

  7. […] no surprise the bad case studies are shared over and over and over again. WhenChick-fil-A had their train wreck of an issue because their CEO came out against the gay and lesbian community, the best content was about why […]

  8. […] no surprise the bad case studies are shared over and over and over again. When Chick-fil-A had their train wreck of an issue because their CEO came out against the gay and lesbian community, the best blog content was about […]